Digitizing Tapes in 2025
My friend ended up with a big box of vidoe tapes from their childhood from VHS, Video8, and MiniDV.
I have been given / volunteered for / chose to digitize these and I’m trying to strike a reasonable balance between cost, quality, and effort.
There is some very interesting work happening with softwared defined decoding in the VHS-Decode project but it’s a little more moving parts and soldering than I want to do right now. Perhaps in a few years when I can buy a single piece of hardware for a few hundred dollars I’ll revisit this.
1. First attempt: Try to get everything via an analog capture card
Camcorder -> Composite / S Video -> Black Magic Intensity Extreme -> Computer
Bought a used BlackMagic Intensity Extreme including a Thunderbolt cable which claims to be able to capture NTSC (fun fact, this is literally the first time I have ever touched a Thunderbolt cable!). These are pretty cheap. I read online that this isn’t great but I hoped it would be Good Enough™️.
It wasn’t!! Lots of black frames and stuttering. The video wasn’t watchable.
2. Second attempt: Convert the MiniDV tapes via FireWire
These should be the easiest. It’s digital data stored on tapes. The camcorder has a FireWire port on it… but I don’t own any devices with a FireWire port.
Apple made a FireWire to Thunderbolt adapter (MD464LL) which I could plug in to my 2014 MacBook Pro with Thunderbolt but they’re pretty pricey on eBay at this point.
2.1 PCIe FireWire card via USB
PCIe FireWire cards are cheap… but I live in an NYC apartment and don’t have computer with a PCIe slot lying around.
Camcorder FireWire -> PCIe FireWire card -> PCIe to M2 Adapter -> USB M2 NVMe Adapter -> Computer
Edit: This doesn’t work
M.2 NVMe to USB adapter $16M.2 M-Key to PCIe adapter $10LinksTek 4-Ports 1394A PCIE FireWire 400 card $20
~Total cost $50. I probably should have just bit the bullet and waited for an Apple adapter to pop up for $100 and avoided this horrible chain of converters.
2.2 FireWire -> Thunderbolt adapter
Camcorder FireWire -> Belkin Dock -> Apple Thunderbolt 2 to 3 (USB-C) Adapter -> M1 MacBook Pro
This works!
Instead of the pricey Apple adapter, you can get a Thunderbolt dock with a FireWire port! I got the Belkin Thunderbolt Express Dock F4U055 on eBay for $29 + shipping. It’s big and bulky and requires an external power supply but it worked without any fuss or driver installation. If you have a Mac with a Thunderbolt port you can open iMovie and get to work!
I was able to buy a used Thunderbolt 3 (USB-C) to Thunderbolt 2 adapter cheaply allowing me to use this dock with iMovie and Final Cut Pro X on my M1 Macbook Pro (Sequoia 15.5). Again, no issues!
Warning:
Apple removed support for FireWire in MacOS 26. I assume that will break this setup.
Note:
There doesn’t seem to be much difference between importing videos via FireWire via iMovie and Final Cut Pro X. FCPX offers some options like “Remove Pulldown in video”, “Balance color”, and “Find people” for video and “Fix audio problems”, “Separate mono and group stereo audio”, “remove silent channels” for audio but I’m not using any of them. If you only have iMovie I wouldn’t rush out to buy a copy of FCPX.
3. Step 3: Get the Video8 via another camcorder with Passthrough to FireWire
I want to follow the instructions on page 88 of this manual. All of this to be continued as soon as I find a camcorder with both FireWire passthrough and a TBC on eBay…